Muhammad Bin Ishaq (Rahimahullah) Muhadithseen Ki Nazar Mein

1) Imam Shuba Bin Al-Hajaj (Rahimahullah) ne farmaya:

محمد بن اسحاق صدوق في الحديث

Muhammad Bin Ishaq hadith mein sodooq (sachay) hai. {Jarh Wa Tadeel, Jild no.7, Safa no.192, Sanad Sahih}

Aur farmaya:

محمد بن اسحاق امير المحدثين

Muhadithseen k ameer Muhammad Bin Ishaq. {Jarh Wa Tadeel, Jild no.7, Safa no.192, Sanad Hasan}

Scan: http://i.imgur.com/INpKGoy.jpg

Imam Shuba (Rahimahullah) ne ek revayat mein farmaya:

محمد بن اسحاق امير المحدثين بحفظه

wo apne hafizay ki waja say muhadithseen k ameer thy. {Juz Qiraat, Hadith no.142, sanad sahih, Tareek-e-kabeer, Jild no.1, Safa no.40}

Scan: http://i.imgur.com/skHVZrz.jpg
Scan: http://i.imgur.com/mDdQUek.jpg

Aur farmaya:

ابن إسحاق سيد المحدثين لحال حفظه

Ibn Ishaq apne hafizay ki waja say muhadithseen k sardaar thy. {Tareekh-e-Bagdad , Jild no.2, Safa 26-27, Sanad Sahih} Continue reading

Kya “La Salata Liman Lamyaqra Bi Fatehatil Kitab” hadith aam nahi hai?

Bilkul yeh hadith aam hai jis k kuch dalail pesh-e-khidmat hai:

1.Is hadith k jo rawe Sahabi-e-Rasool Ubaida Bin Samit (Radiallahu Ahnu) hai wo fateha khalfal imam k qayil thy:

Imam Ibn Abi Shaiba (Rahimahullah) farmate hai:

حدثنا وكيع عن بن عون عن رجاء بن حيوة عن محمود بن ربيع قال صليت صلاة وإلى جنبي عبادة بن الصامت قال فقرأ بفاتحة الكتاب قال فقلت له يا أبا الوليد ألم أسمعك تقرأ بفاتحة الكتاب قال أجل إنه لا صلاة إلا بها

Mahmood Bin Rabi’a farmate hai: Main ne ek nimaz pade aur Meray saath Ubaida Bin Samit (Radiallhu Anhu) thy, Unhoo ne Surah Fateha pade, Main ne Un say kaha Ae Abu Waleed! Kya Main ne Aapko Surah Fateha padte hue nahi suna? Toh Unhoo ne farmaya:Ji haan aur is k bagair koi nimaaz nahi hote hai.
Continue reading

“The Evidences and Athaar for Reciting Faatihah Behind the Imaam”

Khaas Dalaail (Specific Evidences):

1. The narration of Anas (radiallah anhu):

Translation:
Mahmood (b. Ishaaq) narrated to us, (he) said: Al-Bukhari narrated to us, (he) said: Yahya b. Yusuf (Al-Zami) narrated to us, Ubaidullah (b. Amr al-Raqi) informed us, From Ayyub (b. Abi Tameemah As-Sakhtiyani), From Abu Qilabah (Abdullah b. Zayd Al-Jarmi), From Anas [radiallah anhu] that:
Verily the Prophet [peace be upon him] led his companions in prayer, thus when he finished his prayer, he said while facing towards them: “Do you recite in your prayer when the Imam is reciting?” thus they remained silent, so he [peace be upon him] asked this three times. Thus one or many people said: “Certainly we do so.” He [peace be upon him] said: “thus do not do so, and everyone of you should recite Surah Faatihah to your self (silently).” Continue reading